Justification and assessment determines Kaniva lake not feasible

Published on 03 January 2025

West Wimmera Shire Council has concluded that construction of a man-made lake in Kaniva is not feasible at this time, following a thorough investigation and cost analysis.

Council investigated constructing a 200m by 400m lake at the Kaniva Racecourse Reserve after receiving the idea from the community.

The lake would have a depth of two metres, meaning it could be used for water skiing and other water activities. It would have a capacity of 140 megalitres.

Initial concept design cost estimates for the project ranged from $6.5 million to $13 million, with substantial ongoing operational and maintenance expenses also considered.

The project would have required the excavation of the lake, disposal of earth, lining of the lake, water supply infrastructure, and additional amenities, including a boat ramp and jetty.

One of the most significant challenges identified was securing a reliable water supply, which would have added further complexity and cost to the project.

Council does not own the racecourse, and only has a management role in how the land is used.

Therefore, the proposed lake would require significant approvals from multiple agencies, including the Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action (DEECA), the EPA, Wimmera Catchment Management Authority, GWMWater, and the Barengi Gadjin Land Council, including a cultural heritage study.

Council Chief Executive Officer David Bezuidenhout said the substantial construction and ongoing operational and maintenance costs, combined with complexity and uncertainty surrounding approval processes, led to the determination that the project would not be viable.

“Council’s role is to consider all project ideas carefully, balancing priorities in our Council Plan, including cost-benefits and sustainability,” he said.

“This proposal was no exception, and after evaluating the full scope of the project, it became evident that it would not be prudent to proceed with the project at this time.”

Council remains committed to exploring recreational opportunities in West Wimmera Shire and will continue to engage with the community to understand their needs.